有人真的设计过吗？ [英] Does anyone actually design?

问题描述

我已经在这个领域工作了20年。在我所有的学校教育中，在那段时间里，我学会了OO和程序设计技巧的原理。除了在我职业生涯开始的2年时间里，我参与过的大多数软件项目从未做过任何类型的正式设计（更不用说分析了）。软件工程师实际设计 - 从分析？从要求？



我尝试过：



截至最近，我在现场谈过的大多数专业人士，当谈到整理设计时，看起来像我奇怪或不知道我在说什么 - 或者指的是某种文档。

I have been in this field for 20 years. In all my "schooling", in that time, I have learned the principles of both OO and Procedural design techniques. Aside from a 2 year stint at the beginning of my career, most software projects I have been a part never did any type of formal design (let alone analysis). Do software engineers actually design--from analysis? From requirements?

What I have tried:

As of recent, most professionals that I have talked to in the field, look at me like I am "odd" or "do not know what I am talking about" when it comes to putting together a design--and or referring to some sort of documentation.

推荐答案

是的，每个人都设计，但这种设计可能只是在头脑中，主要是过去的经验和类似的应用程序结构。



问题在于设计随着敏捷运动的激增而得到了不好的说唱，前提是前期设计等于瀑布，这是不好的。



就个人而言，我的设计主要是笔记本（纸张）中的设计选择，伪代码片段，用户要求和方框图的列表。

Yes everybody designs, but that design may be only in the head, mostly on past experience and similar application structure.

The problem is that "design" has been given a bad rap with the proliferation of the "agile" movement, the premise being that upfront design is equal to "waterfall" which is bad.

On a personal note, my designs are mostly lists of design choices, pseudo code snippets, user requirements and block diagrams in a notebook (paper).

引用：

有没有人真正设计？

是的，这就是工作。

Yes all the time, that is the job.

引用：

软件工程师实际设计 - - 从分析？来自要求？

Do software engineers actually design--from analysis? From requirements?

来自需求的SE设计分析（很棒）。

来自分析的SE设计代码（精炼细节）。

如果你不是在玩具以外的项目上做，那么有人会为你做分析而你只是在撒尿。

SE design analysis (great lines) from requirements.
SE design code from analysis (refining details).
If you don't do it on projects that are more than toys, someone do analysis for you and you are just peeing code.

这篇关于有人真的设计过吗？的文章就介绍到这了，希望我们推荐的答案对大家有所帮助，也希望大家多多支持IT屋！