Android的QR扫描仪/阅读器应用程序的独立，而无需安装应用程序zxing - 它是非法的/法律，还有什么可除了zxing [英] Android QR Scanner/Reader App standalone without having to install zxing App - Is it Illegal/Legal-Anything else available apart from zxing

问题描述

我已经研究了很多关于使用QR code扫描仪和放大器创建自己的应用程序为Android;读者无需在手机上安装应用程序Zxing。
我已经经历了很多的问题，走了也在这里，我已经读它通过一个或所有以下链接是可能的： -

I have researched a lot about creating my own app for android with a QR code Scanner & Reader without having to install Zxing app on the phone. I have gone through a lot of questions here too and I have read it is possible via one or all of the following links:-

http://jmanzano.me /集成-zxing-在我们-自有的Andr​​oid应用吧codescanner /

<一个href=\"http://stackoverflow.com/questions/4782543/integration-zxing-library-directly-into-my-android-application\">Integration直接ZXing库到我的Andr​​oid应用程序

<一个href=\"http://damianflannery.word$p$pss.com/2011/06/13/integrate-zxing-bar$c$c-scanner-into-your-android-app-natively-using-eclipse/\" rel=\"nofollow\">http://damianflannery.word$p$pss.com/2011/06/13/integrate-zxing-bar$c$c-scanner-into-your-android-app-natively-using-eclipse/

它是合法的，做这种方式还是我们必须使用意图是什么？
是否有任何其他的开源库，在那里除了zxing在那里我可以用自己的库集成到我的项目。

Is it legal to do it this way or do we have to use intent? Are there any other open source libraries out there apart from zxing where I could use their library to integrate into my project.

推荐答案

我是作者，以及大多数你问的评论的来源。只要你遵循Apache许可证2.0条款（见这里评论一>），您必须使用许可证项目的版权作品几乎任何目的。

I'm the author and the source of most the comments you're asking about. As long as you follow the terms of the Apache License 2.0 (see comments here), you have license to use the copyrighted work of the project for just about any purpose.

我不重用的code（按照上文）劝退任何人，甚至一些来自酒吧code扫描仪，因为它毕竟是开源的，由作者已经送人要造福于社会。我非常不赞成的整体大幅复制项目的到的应用程序。有几个方面的原因：

I'm not discouraging anyone from reusing the code (in accordance with above), even some from Barcode Scanner, as it is after all open-source and has been given away by the authors to be benefit the community. I am strongly discouraging copying the project substantially in its entirety into an app. There are a few reasons for this:

• 人们通常复制的Andr​​oidManifest.xml 及其声明。这使得以注定了吧code扫描仪的应用程序，意图 S中克隆应用程序响应。它不方便或打破了我们的应用程序和其他用户体验。也不好。


• 复制熟悉的项目UI会让人觉得他们正在使用酒吧code扫描仪时，他们没有。还有的商标潜在的法律问题这里，如果你的产品是混淆性相似到另一个。开放源代码的许可并不授予商标专用权。


• 您的应用的问题可能会向我们报告作为项目的错误结果。开发商要求做这种嵌入肯定不问了很多的邮件列表上的帮助了。通过使别人支持你的应用程序损害了整个社区。
  

• People usually copy AndroidManifest.xml and its declarations. This makes the clone app respond to Intents that were meant for the Barcode Scanner app. It inconveniences or breaks the user experience for our app and others. Not good at all.
• Copying the familiar project UI will make people think they're using Barcode Scanner when they're not. There is a potential legal issue of trademark here if your product is confusingly similar to another. The open source license does not grant trademark rights.
• Your app issues may get reported to us as project bugs as a result. Developers asked to do this embedding sure do ask for a lot of help on the mailing list too. That harms the overall community by making others support your app.

做这样的复制给出的通常的原因是：

The usual reasons given for doing such copying are:

• 这是一个更好的用户体验嵌入扫描。也许是这样，但是，您可以编写自己的应用程序扫描，或者至少是自己的UI。我不知道这是一个更好的用户体验无论是。例如，如果使用意图，您的用户可以与你没有获得，像的酒吧code扫描仪+ 或护目镜。


• 我公司不会让我使用第三方应用程序。也许吧，但它只是识别别人谁是作出决定，而不是证明它。如果它是安全的原因 - 这同样适用很好地嵌入第三方code

• It's a better user experience to embed the scanning. Maybe so, but, you can write your own scanning app, or at least your own UI. I am not sure it is a better user experience either. For example, if using Intents, your users can scan with better specialist apps that you don't have access to, like Barcode Scanner+ or Goggles.
• My company won't let me use a third-party app. Maybe, but it's just identifying someone else who's making the decision, not justifying it. If it's for 'security' reasons -- these apply equally well to embedding third-party code.

这些理由都​​只能归结为它会让我少的钱。我不认为他们超过上述问题，肯定不回答商标问题。我对模仿者一点同情，尤其是在看到在刚刚添加的广告，或者市场如此多的克隆在一种情况下，恶意软件。

These reasons tend to boil down to "it will make me less money." I don't think they outweigh the issues above, and certainly do not answer the trademark issue. I have little sympathy for the copycats, especially having seen so many clones in the Market that just add ads, or in one case, malware.

这篇关于Android的QR扫描仪/阅读器应用程序的独立，而无需安装应用程序zxing - 它是非法的/法律，还有什么可除了zxing的文章就介绍到这了，希望我们推荐的答案对大家有所帮助，也希望大家多多支持IT屋！