XML和XSD-使用元素名称替换xsi:type以实现多态 [英] XML and XSD - use element name as replacement of xsi:type for polymorphism

问题描述

以W3C车辆XSD为例:

Taking the W3C vehicle XSD as an example:

<schema xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"
           targetNamespace="http://cars.example.com/schema"
           xmlns:target="http://cars.example.com/schema">

  <complexType name="Vehicle" abstract="true"/>

  <complexType name="Car">
    <complexContent>
      <extension base="target:Vehicle"/>
      ...
    </complexContent>
  </complexType>

  <complexType name="Plane">
    <complexContent>
      <extension base="target:Vehicle"/>
      <sequence>
        <element name="wingspan" type="integer"/>
      </sequence>
    </complexContent>
  </complexType>      
</schema>

，以及"meansOfTravel"的以下定义:

, and the following definition of 'meansOfTravel':

<complexType name="MeansOfTravel">
  <complexContent>
    <sequence>        
      <element name="transport" type="target:Vehicle"/>        
    </sequence>
  </complexContent>
</complexType>

<element name="meansOfTravel" type="target:MeansOfTravel"/>

使用此定义，您需要使用xsi:type指定实例的类型，如下所示:

With this definition you need to specify the type of your instance using xsi:type, like this:

<meansOfTravel>
  <transport xsi:type="Plane">
     <wingspan>3</wingspan>
  </transport>
</meansOfTravel>

我只想实现类型名称"-元素名称"映射，以便可以将其替换为公正"

I would just like to acheive a 'name of type' - 'name of element' mapping so that this could be replaced with just

<meansOfTravel>
  <plane>
    <wingspan>3</wingspan>
  </plane>
</meansOfTravel>

直到现在，我唯一可以做的就是将它明确化:

The only way I could do this until now is by making it explicit:

<complexType name="MeansOfTravel">
  <sequence>        
    <choice>
      <element name="plane" type="target:Plane"/>
      <element name="car" type="target:Car"/>         
    </choice>
  </sequence>
</complexType>

<element name="meansOfTravel" type="target:MeansOfTravel"/>

但这意味着我必须在"MeansOfTravel"复杂类型中列出所有可能的子类型.如果调用元素"plane"，是否无法使XML解析器假设您的意思是"Plane"?还是我必须做出明确的选择?我只想让我的设计保持干燥-如果您还有其他建议(例如团体建议)，我会不知所措.

But this means that I have to list all possible sub-types in the 'MeansOfTravel' complex type. Is there no way of making the XML parser assume that you mean a 'Plane' if you call the element 'plane'? Or do I have to make the choice explicit? I would just like to keep my design DRY - if you have any other suggestions (like groups or so) - i am all ears.

推荐答案

围绕它有一个通用的设计模式，您可以使用子类型(如您已经做的那样)以及替换组中的元素.替换组中的元素必须是被替换元素的子类型.

There is a common design pattern around this, you can use sub-types (as you are already doing), and elements in a substitution group. Elements in the substitution group have to be of a sub-type of the element they are substituted for.

不幸的是，替换组元素需要定义为全局元素.因此，您将拥有:

Unfortuntaly, substitution group elements need to be defined as global elements. So you would have this:

<complexType name="MeansOfTravel">
  <complexContent>
    <sequence>        
      <element ref="transport"/>
    </sequence>
  </complexContent>
</complexType>

<element name="transport" type="target:Vehicle"/>
<element name="plane" type="target:Plane" substitutionGroup="target:transport"/>

然后，您可以在XML文档中使用:

Then, in your XML document you can use:

<meansOfTravel>
    <plane>...</plane>
</meansOfTravel>

有关替代组的更多信息，请此处.而且不，不幸的是，解析器无法猜测到这一点，因此，您仍然必须列出元素:(但是，相对于选择而言，有一个优势:模式可以通过导入而无需修改而从外部扩展.选择不能扩展

More info on substitution groups here. And no, unfortunately the parser cannot guess this, so you still have to list the elements :( There is one advantage over a choice though: the schema can be extended externally, by importing it, without modifying it. The choice could not be extended.

这篇关于XML和XSD-使用元素名称替换xsi:type以实现多态的文章就介绍到这了，希望我们推荐的答案对大家有所帮助，也希望大家多多支持IT屋！