创建一个新的CMS，从ASP中导入内容-Umbraco还是Sharepoint？ [英] Creating a new CMS, importing content from ASP - Umbraco or Sharepoint?

问题描述

我正在一个创建CMS的项目中，这将需要导入很多现有内容，其中大部分是静态的，但是在ASP中（因此它们不仅是纯HTML的，还包括一些内容，有时其他服务器端代码）。

I'm working on a project to create a CMS, which will entail importing a lot of existing content, most of which is static, but in ASP (so they're not all just pure HTML, there are includes and sometimes other server-side code).

我们正在考虑使用Umbraco或Sharepoint（2010）来管理外部内容，该内容目前包含数千页。我已经阅读了这，我认为双方都有很好的理由。但是，尽管我已经了解了添加和管理内容的功能，但是对于将现有内容导入其中的任何内容我都没有看到。而且由于我们必须导入很多内容，因此任何一个CMS都可以方便地执行此操作将是决定的主要因素。

We're considering using Umbraco or Sharepoint (2010) for managing the external content, which currently comprises a few thousand pages. I've read this and I think there are good cases to be made for both sides. However, while I've read about the features of adding and managing content, I have not seen anything regarding the importing of existing content into either. And since we have a lot of content that will have to be imported, the ability of either CMS to facilitate this will be a major factor in the decision.

想知道是否有人有尝试将大量内容导入Umbraco或Sharepoint的经验，或者您是否知道我可能会怎么做。容易吗？有没有我可以找到的插件，或者我可以写的脚本？还是我需要使用CMS手动导入每个现有文件？

I'd like to know if anyone has any experience trying to import a lot of content into either Umbraco or Sharepoint, or if you have any idea how I might go about doing that. Is it easy for either? Are there plug-ins I can find, or scripts I can write? Or will I pretty much have to import each existing file manually with either CMS?

如果您有Umbraco或Sharepoint的经验，对此有任何想法，我会很重视您的输入和/或建议。

If you have experience with Umbraco or Sharepoint and have any ideas about this, I would value your input and/or recommendations.

推荐答案

您是否只是将SharePoint用作CMS？恕我直言，虽然SharePoint可以用作CMS，但这并不是其真正优势所在-它更适合Intranet / Portals / Collaboration工具。

Are you just using SharePoint as a CMS? IMHO whilst SharePoint can be used as a CMS that is not where its real strengths lie - its more suited to Intranet/Portals/Collaboration tools.

我相信有人会在一分钟之内即可打开指向SharePoint展示网站的链接，但缺点是：-

I am sure someone will be on in a minute with links to SharePoint showcase sites but the disadvantages :-

• 价格昂贵（即使使用免费 WSS
  您需要Internet连接器
  许可的版本）和Windows许可。


• 
  标记可能相当繁重，而
  难以自定义（2007年的数据丰富，
  和以
  计的javascript文件kb）


• 2007年可疑的
  跨浏览器功能


• 网站功能相对较差，例如博客引擎与某些专用CMS相比

• Its expensive (even with 'free' WSS version you need Internet connector license) + windows licenses.
• The markup can be fairly 'heavy' and difficult to customise (tables galore in 2007 and javascript files measured in hundreds of kb)
• Questionable cross browser functionality in 2007
• Relatively poor 'website' features e.g. blogging engine as compared to some dedicated CMS's

基本上-如果您所追求的只是CMS，那么也许还有更好的选择？

Basically - if all you are after is a CMS then perhaps there are better options?

（我应该说，我认为在Intranet / Portal环境中，SharePoint十分出色，有时确实令人沮丧，但非常出色）。

这篇关于创建一个新的CMS，从ASP中导入内容-Umbraco还是Sharepoint？的文章就介绍到这了，希望我们推荐的答案对大家有所帮助，也希望大家多多支持IT屋！