R nls 奇异梯度 [英] R nls singular gradient

问题描述

我已尝试搜索有关此主题的其他线程，但没有任何修复对我有用.我有一个自然实验的结果，我想显示符合指数分布的事件连续发生的次数.我的R shell粘贴在下面

I've tried searching the other threads on this topic but none of the fixes are working for me. I have the results of a natural experiment and I want to show the number of consecutive occurrences of an event fit an exponential distribution. My R shell is pasted below

f <- function(x,a,b) {a * exp(b * x)}
> x
 [1]  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
[26] 26 27
> y
 [1] 1880  813  376  161  100   61   31    9    8    2    7    4    3    2    0
[16]    1    0    0    0    0    0    1    0    0    0    0    1
> dat2
    x    y
1   1 1880
2   2  813
3   3  376
4   4  161
5   5  100
6   6   61
7   7   31
8   8    9
9   9    8
10 10    2
11 11    7
12 12    4
13 13    3
14 14    2
> fm <- nls(y ~ f(x,a,b), data = dat2, start = c(a=1, b=1)) 
Error in numericDeriv(form[[3L]], names(ind), env) : 
  Missing value or an infinity produced when evaluating the model
> fm <- nls(y ~ f(x,a,b), data = dat2, start = c(a=7, b=-.5)) 
Error in nls(y ~ f(x, a, b), data = dat2, start = c(a = 7, b = -0.5)) : 
  singular gradient
> fm <- nls(y ~ f(x,a,b), data = dat2, start = c(a=7,b=-.5),control=nls.control(maxiter=1000,warnOnly=TRUE,minFactor=1e-5,tol=1e-10),trace=TRUE) 
4355798 :   7.0 -0.5
Warning message:
In nls(y ~ f(x, a, b), data = dat2, start = c(a = 7, b = -0.5),  :
  singular gradient

请原谅格式错误，先在这里发帖.x 包含直方图的 bin，y 包含该直方图中每个 bin 的出现次数.dat2 在 14 处截止，因为 0 计数仓会甩掉指数回归，我真的只需要拟合前 14 个.那些计数超过 14 的仓我有生物学上的理由相信它们是特殊的.我最初遇到的问题是无穷大，因为没有一个值为 0，所以我没有得到这个问题.在按照不同帖子的建议给出合适的起始值之后，我得到了奇异梯度误差.我看到的唯一其他帖子有更多变量，我尝试增加迭代次数，但没有成功.任何帮助表示赞赏.一个

Please forgive the bad formatting, first post here. x contains bins of a histogram, y contains the number of occurrences of each bin in that histograms. dat2 cuts off at 14 since the 0 count bins would throw off the exponential regression, and I really only need to fit those first 14. Those bins which have counts beyond 14 I have biological reason to believe they are special. The issue I initially got was infinity, which I don't get since none of the values are 0. After giving decent starting values as suggested by a different post here I get the singular gradient error. The only other posts I saw with that had more variables, I tried increasing the number of iterations but that did not succeed. Any help is appreciated. A

推荐答案

1) 线性化以获得起始值 你需要更好的起始值:

1) linearize to get starting values You need better starting values:

# starting values
fm0 <- nls(log(y) ~ log(f(x, a, b)), dat2, start = c(a = 1, b = 1))

nls(y ~ f(x, a, b), dat2, start = coef(fm0))

给予:

Nonlinear regression model
  model: y ~ f(x, a, b)
   data: x
        a         b 
4214.4228   -0.8106 
 residual sum-of-squares: 2388

Number of iterations to convergence: 6 
Achieved convergence tolerance: 3.363e-06

1a) 类似地，我们可以使用 lm 来获得初始值

1a) Similarly we could use lm to get the initial value by writing

y ~ a * exp(b * x)

作为

y ~ exp(log(a) + b * x)

并取两者的对数以获得 log(a) 和 b 中的线性模型:

and taking logs of both to get a model linear in log(a) and b:

log(y) ~ log(a) + b * x

可以使用lm解决:

fm_lm <- lm(log(y) ~ x, dat2)
st <- list(a = exp(coef(fm_lm)[1]), b = coef(fm_lm)[2])
nls(y ~ f(x, a, b), dat2, start = st)

给予:

Nonlinear regression model
  model: y ~ f(x, a, b)
   data: dat2
       a        b 
4214.423   -0.811 
 residual sum-of-squares: 2388

Number of iterations to convergence: 6 
Achieved convergence tolerance: 3.36e-06

1b) 我们还可以通过重新参数化来使其工作.在这种情况下，如果我们根据参数转换来转换初始值，则 a = 1 和 b = 1 将起作用.

1b) We can also get it to work by reparameterizing. In that case a = 1 and b = 1 will work provided we transform the initial values in line with the parameter transformation.

nls(y ~ exp(loga + b * x), dat2, start = list(loga = log(1), b = 1))

给予:

Nonlinear regression model
  model: y ~ exp(loga + b * x)
   data: dat2
  loga      b 
 8.346 -0.811 
 residual sum-of-squares: 2388

Number of iterations to convergence: 20 
Achieved convergence tolerance: 3.82e-07

所以 b 如图所示，a = exp(loga) = exp(8.346) = 4213.3

so b is as shown and a = exp(loga) = exp(8.346) = 4213.3

2) plinear 另一种更简单的可能性是使用 alg="plinear" 在这种情况下，线性输入的参数不需要起始值.在这种情况下，问题中 b=1 的起始值似乎就足够了.

2) plinear Another possibility that is even easier is to use alg="plinear" in which case starting values are not needed for the parameters entering linearly. In that case the starting value of b=1 in the question seems sufficient.

nls(y ~ exp(b * x), dat2, start = c(b = 1), alg = "plinear")

给予:

Nonlinear regression model
  model: y ~ exp(b * x)
   data: dat2
        b      .lin 
  -0.8106 4214.4234 
 residual sum-of-squares: 2388

Number of iterations to convergence: 11 
Achieved convergence tolerance: 2.153e-06

这篇关于R nls 奇异梯度的文章就介绍到这了，希望我们推荐的答案对大家有所帮助，也希望大家多多支持IT屋！