RestController 设计之争 - Spring Boot REST API [英] RestController design struggle - Spring Boot REST API

问题描述

我对 REST API 开发很陌生.我决定使用 Spring Boot 创建一个博客应用程序，但我真的在为我的应用程序的设计和结构而苦苦挣扎.

I'm quite new into REST API development. I have decided to create a Blog application using Spring Boot and I'm really struggling with the design and structure of my app.

现在我的应用由 Post 和 Comment 模型和存储库组成.对于这两种模型，我都创建了服务类(PostService 和 CommentService).在这些类中，我拥有所有业务逻辑(现在只是简单的 CRUD).

Right now my app consists of Post and Comment models and repositories. For both models, I have created service classes (PostService and CommentService). In these classes, I have all the business logic (just simple CRUD right now).

现在我正在为我的帖子@RestControler 的设计而挠头.在 PostController 中，我公开了这些操作:

Now I am scratching my head about the design of my @RestControler for Posts. In PostController I have exposed these actions:

@PostMapping("/api/posts/create")
public Post create(@RequestBody Post post) { ... }

@GetMapping("/api/posts")
public List<Post> findAll() { ... }

@GetMapping("/api/posts/{id}")
public Post findById(@PathVariable("id") Long id) { ... }

@PutMapping("/api/posts/{id}")
public Post update(@RequestBody Post post) { ... }

@DeleteMapping("/api/posts/{id}")
public void delete(@PathVariable Long id) { ... }

现在我要回答我的问题了.我想知道在帖子中添加评论的正确设计是什么.

Now I'm getting to my question. I am wondering what is correct design of adding a Comment to the Post.

1. 是否应该使用 CommentController 类公开所有用于 Comment 的 CRUD 方法并使用 create 方法?
2. 是否可以向 PostController 添加新方法 addComment 以创建新评论?

1. Should I expose all CRUD method for Comment using CommentController class and use create method?
2. Is it ok to add a new method addComment to PostController which will create a new Comment?

在我的脑海里给帖子添加评论属于帖子，但我真的不知道.

In my head adding a Comment to the Post belongs to the Post, but I really don't know.

有人可以就这件事给我一些建议吗?

Could some of give me some advice regarding this matter?

非常感谢！

再见，汤姆

推荐答案

如果我是你，我会考虑 OpenAPI 规范 并将遵循 resource ->子资源 ->方法||标识符 模式.出于可读性和理解目的，这可能是最亲吻和最干净的设计.

If I were you, I'd consider REST Design Principles from the OpenAPI Specification and would follow resource -> sub-resource -> method||identifier pattern. This would probably be the most KISS and clean design for the readability and understanding purposes.

@PostMapping("/api/posts/") //you don't need /create as a separate URI
public Post create(@RequestBody Post post) { ... }

@GetMapping("/api/posts") //This is OK.
public List<Post> findAll() { ... }

@GetMapping("/api/posts/{id}") //OK, however {id} should be optional, hence you can combine this and upper methods in one method.
public Post findById(@PathVariable("id") Long id) { ... }

@PutMapping("/api/posts/{id}") //OK.
public Post update(@RequestBody Post post) { ... }

@DeleteMapping("/api/posts/{id}") //OK.
public void delete(@PathVariable Long id) { ... }

现在，对于评论 API 设计，我会将它们包含在 posts 资源下，并添加这些相应的 URI:

and now, for the comments API design, I would have contain them under posts resource, and would have added these corresponding URIs:

@GetMapping("/api/posts/{id}/comments/{commendId}") //commentId is optional
@PostMapping("/api/posts/{id}/comments/") //you don't need any {commendId} here, just post the payload

等等.我希望你能想出方法签名和其他方法映射.

and etc. I hope you can come up with method signatures and other method mappings.

您还可以在此处

这篇关于RestController 设计之争 - Spring Boot REST API的文章就介绍到这了，希望我们推荐的答案对大家有所帮助，也希望大家多多支持IT屋！