HTML5 是否仅取代 Flash/Silverlight 的视频方面? [英] Does HTML5 only replace the video aspects of Flash/Silverlight?

问题描述

我看到很多关于 HTML5 视频标签如何杀死 Flash 的讨论.但是，虽然视频是 Flash/SL 中使用最广泛的部分，但这只是它们技术能力的一小部分.例如，您可以使用 Flex 中的全 3D 图形和套接字连接以及严肃的商业应用程序等编写游戏.

I see a lot of talk how HTML5 video tag will kill Flash. But while video is the most widely used part of Flash/SL, it's only a small part of their technical abilities. For instance you can write a game using full 3D graphics and socket connections in Flex, and serious business applications, etc.

是否认为 Javascript 会杀死 Flash/Flex/SL 的那些部分?因为虽然现在对于非常丰富的网络应用来说这似乎是可行的，但对于实时图形等任何类型的高性能应用呢?

Is the thinking that Javascript will kill those parts of Flash/Flex/SL? Because while that seems feasible now for even quite rich web-apps, what about any kind of high-performance app like real-time graphics?

推荐答案

我参与的关于这个主题的讨论几乎总是得出这样的结论，虽然 HTML 5 标准将是一个伟大的事物，一旦就位.根据定义，这将是一个标准，标准需要很长时间才能改变，因此创新将主要由 Flash 和 SL 等插件驱动.

The discussions I've been part of on this subject, pretty much always seem to come to the conclusion that, while the HTML 5 standard will be a a great thing, once it's in place. It will by definition be a standard, standards take a long time to change, therefore innovation will be driven largely by plugins like Flash and SL.

是的，你可以用 Javascript 做很多 Flash 和 SL 可以做的事情，但是 Flash/Flex 的强项是用于桌面安装的 Air 应用程序，而 Silverlight 的Out Of Browser"也有类似的东西功能.在这些方面，他们显然比 Javascript 具有优势.

And yes you can do a lot of what Flash and SL can do with Javascript, however Flash/Flex has the strong point of being used for desktop installed Air applications, and Silverlight has the similar thing with their "Out Of Browser" functionality. These are things where they clearly have the upper hand over Javascript.

归根结底，这不是谁会杀死谁的问题，而是哪种工具适合这项工作以及您/您的开发团队拥有哪些技能.

At the end of the day it's not a matter of who will kill who, but rather which tool is the right one for the job and what skills does you / your development team have.

无论如何那是我的 2c...

That's my 2c anyway...

这篇关于HTML5 是否仅取代 Flash/Silverlight 的视频方面?的文章就介绍到这了，希望我们推荐的答案对大家有所帮助，也希望大家多多支持IT屋！