结合期货（Twitter）和Scala中的任何一种 [英] Combining Futures (Twitter) and Either in Scala

问题描述

我们使用Twitter的期货（作为Finagle堆栈的一部分），我不喜欢使用（业务）异常来控制应用程序流程的概念，因为异常不会显示在方法签名中。

所以我有主意使用Future [Either [A，B]]代替。

使用这个概念来理解期货存在一些问题：

例如我们有一个存储库方法：

  def getUserCredentialsByNickname（nickname：String）：Future [Either [EntityNotFound，UserCredentials]] 
  

和一个处理程序方法，该方法使用此存储库并执行其他一些检查并还创建令牌

  def过程（请求：LoginRequest）：Future [Either [Failure，Login]] = {
 for {
凭据Either< -userRepository.getUserCredentialsByNickname（request.username）
 ...其他应通过打扰来理解的其他呼叫/检查
令牌<-defineToken（凭证）
}产生令牌
  

仅当此调用返回Right时，才执行对getUserCredentialsByNickname（..）之后的for理解的调用。 [UserCredentials]，以及每个返回的Either的详细错误信息都应从处理程序中返回。

解决方案

所以我现在我曾尝试使用Scalaz Either（与中性标量Either相比是偏右的Either）和Monad Transformer EitherT，看来它确实满足了我的要求。

这里是Twitter期货以及Scalaz Either和EitherT的示例：

  import com.twitter.util。{等待，将来} 
导入scalaz。{Monad，Functor，EitherT，\ /} 
 import scalaz.syntax.ToIdOps 
 
对象EitherTest使用ToIdOps {扩展应用程序{
 
 //使Twitter期货与EitherT一起使用
隐式val FutureFunctor = new Functor [未来] {
 def map [A​​，B]（a：未来[A]）（f：A => B）：未来[B] =映射f 
} 
隐式val FutureMonad = new Monad [Future] {
 def point [A]（a：=> A）：Future [A] = Future（a）
 def bind [A，B]（fa： Future [A]）（f：（A）=> Future [B]）：Future [B] = fa flatMap f 
} 
 
 //示例从此处开始：
 
案例类InvalidInfo（错误：字符串）
案例类Response（msg：字符串）
 
 
类ComponentA {
 def foo（fail：布尔值）：Future [\ / [Inva lidInfo，响应]] = {
 if（fail）Future（InvalidInfo（ Error A）。left）else Future（Response（ ComponentA Success）。right）
} 
} 
类ComponentB {
 def bar（失败：布尔值）：Future [\ / [InvalidInfo，响应]] = {
 if（失败）Future（InvalidInfo（ Error B）。 left）else Future（Response（ ComponentB Success）。right）
} 
} 
 
 val a =新的ComponentA 
 val b =新的ComponentB 
 
 val结果=对于{
 resultA<-EitherT（a.foo（false））
 resultB<-EitherT（b.bar（false））
}收益（resultA，resultB）
 
 println（Await.result（result.run））
} 
  

We use Twitter futures (as part of the Finagle stack) and I don't like the concept of using (business) exceptions to control the flow of our application, because exceptions don't show up in method signatures.

So I had the idea to use Future[Either[A,B]] as a replacement.

But I have some problems in using for comprehensions over futures with this concept:

E.g. we have a repository method:

def getUserCredentialsByNickname(nickname: String): Future[Either[EntityNotFound, UserCredentials]]

and a handler method which uses this repo and does some other checks and also creates a token

def process(request: LoginRequest): Future[Either[Failure, Login]] = {
      for {
        credentialsEither <- userRepository.getUserCredentialsByNickname(request.username)
        ...several other calls/checks which should 'interrupt' this for comprehension
        token <- determineToken(credentials)
} yield token

The calls in the for comprehension after the getUserCredentialsByNickname(..) should only be executed if this call returns a Right[UserCredentials], but also the detailed error information from each returned Either should be returned from the handler.

解决方案

So now I've tried to use Scalaz Either (which is a right biased Either compared to the neutral scala Either) and the Monad Transformer EitherT and it seems it does exactly what I want. Thanks to Huw and especially Lars Hupel for hinting me in the right direction.

Here is working a sample for Twitter futures and Scalaz Either and EitherT:

import com.twitter.util.{Await, Future}
import scalaz.{Monad, Functor, EitherT, \/}
import scalaz.syntax.ToIdOps

object EitherTest extends App with ToIdOps{

  // make Twitter futures work with EitherT
  implicit val FutureFunctor = new Functor[Future] {
    def map[A, B](a: Future[A])(f: A => B): Future[B] = a map f
  }
  implicit val FutureMonad = new Monad[Future] {
    def point[A](a: => A): Future[A] = Future(a)
    def bind[A, B](fa: Future[A])(f: (A) => Future[B]): Future[B] = fa flatMap f
  }

  // The example begins here:

  case class InvalidInfo(error: String)
  case class Response(msg: String)


  class ComponentA {
    def foo(fail: Boolean): Future[\/[InvalidInfo, Response]] = {
      if(fail) Future(InvalidInfo("Error A").left) else Future(Response("ComponentA Success").right)
    }
  }
  class ComponentB {
    def bar(fail: Boolean): Future[\/[InvalidInfo, Response]] = {
      if(fail) Future(InvalidInfo("Error B").left) else Future(Response("ComponentB Success").right)
    }
  }

  val a = new ComponentA
  val b = new ComponentB

  val result = for {
    resultA <- EitherT(a.foo(false))
    resultB <- EitherT(b.bar(false))
  } yield (resultA, resultB)

  println(Await.result(result.run))
}

这篇关于结合期货（Twitter）和Scala中的任何一种的文章就介绍到这了，希望我们推荐的答案对大家有所帮助，也希望大家多多支持IT屋！