即使使用预期的输入，Antlr4也会打印“外部输入"错误 [英] Antlr4 is printing 'Extraneous input' error even with expected input

问题描述

我正在尝试使用 OpenSMILES 规范.

语法:

grammar SMILES;

atom: bracket_atom | aliphatic_organic | aromatic_organic | '*';

aliphatic_organic: 'B' | 'C' | 'N' | 'O' | 'S' | 'P' | 'F' | 'Cl' | 'Br' | 'I';
aromatic_organic: 'b' | 'c' | 'n' | 'o' | 's' | 'p';

bracket_atom: '[' isotope? symbol chiral? hcount? charge? atom_class? ']';
symbol: element_symbols | aromatic_symbols | '*';
isotope: NUMBER;
element_symbols: UPPER_CASE_CHAR LOWER_CASE_CHAR?;
aromatic_symbols: 'c' | 'n' | 'o' | 'p' | 's' | 'se' | 'as';

chiral: '@'
        |  '@@'
        |  '@TH1' | '@TH2'
        |  '@AL1' | '@AL2'
        |  '@SP1' | '@SP2' | '@SP3'
        |  '@TB1' | '@TB2' | '@TB3' | DOT DOT DOT | '@TB29' | '@TB30'
        |  '@OH1' | '@OH2' | '@OH3' | DOT DOT DOT | '@OH29' | '@OH30';

hcount: 'H' |  'H' DIGIT;

charge: '-'
        |  '-' DIGIT
        |  '+'
        |  '+' DIGIT
        |  '--'
        |  '++';

atom_class:':' NUMBER;

bond: '-' | '=' | '#' | '$' | ':' | '/' | '\\';
ringbond: (bond? DIGIT |  bond? '%' DIGIT DIGIT);
branched_atom: atom ringbond* branch*?;
branch: '(' chain ')' |  '(' bond chain ')' |  '(' dot chain ')';
chain: branched_atom
    |  chain branched_atom
    |  chain bond branched_atom
    |  chain dot branched_atom;
dot: '.';

DOT: .;
DIGIT: [0-9];
NUMBER: DIGIT+;
UPPER_CASE_CHAR: [A-Z];
LOWER_CASE_CHAR: [a-z];

ONE_TO_NINE: [1-9];

smiles: chain;

WS: [ \t\n\r]+ -> skip ;

当尝试使用AntlrWorks2的TestRig解析以下内容时:

When trying to parse the following using AntlrWorks2's TestRig:

CCc(c1)ccc2[n+]1ccc3c2Nc4c3cccc4

打印以下错误(为简便起见，以下简称):

The following error(s) are printed (shortened for brevity):

line 1:5 extraneous input '1' expecting {'*', '[', 'N', 'O', 'I', 'S', '%', ')',..., DIGIT}
...
line 1:31 extraneous input '4' expecting {<EOF>, '*', '[', 'N', 'O',..., DIGIT}

在字符串中遇到的每个数字都会发生这种情况.

This happens for every digit that is encountered in the string.

编辑1

按照@Lucas Trzesniewski的建议修复DOT规则后，extraneous input错误已消失.但是，现在在测试其他SMILES字符串时会出现一个新错误.

After fixing the DOT rule, as suggested by @Lucas Trzesniewski, the extraneous input error has disappeared. However, a new error is present now when testing a different SMILES string.

例如，测试:

[Cu+2].[O-]S(=O)(=O)[O-]

产生错误:

line 1:1 no viable alternative at input 'C'

编辑2

编辑1 中的问题是由于我的element_symbols规则引起的.使用文字符号字符串似乎已经解决了该问题.

Problem from EDIT 1 was due to my element_symbols rule. Using the literal symbol strings seems to have solved it.

element_symbols: 'H' | 'He' | 'Li' | 'Be' | 'B' | 'C' | 'N' | 'O' | 'F' | 'Ne' | //...and so on

推荐答案

您的词法分析器规则不正确.

Your lexer rules are wrong.

第一个错误:

DOT: .;

这是万能的.你真正的意思是:

This is a catch-all. What you really mean is:

DOT: '.';

第二个错误:您对以下规则感到困惑:

Second error: You're getting confused with the following rules:

DIGIT: [0-9];
NUMBER: DIGIT+;
ONE_TO_NINE: [1-9];

ONE_TO_NINE永远不会匹配任何内容，因为它包含在DIGIT中，并且DIGIT首先出现.由于从未使用ONE_TO_NINE规则，因此您只需删除它即可.

ONE_TO_NINE will never match anything, because it's included in DIGIT, and DIGIT appears first. As the ONE_TO_NINE rule is never used, so you should simply remove it.

然后，解析器规则中的DIGIT DIGIT之类的东西将不匹配，如果您期望一个2位数的数字，那么您将在那里获得一个NUMBER令牌，除非您用空格将数字分开(我不会不知道您在那儿的真正意思是什么，所以也许这不是一个错误.)

Then, things like DIGIT DIGIT in your parser rules won't match either if you're expecting a 2-digit number, you'll get a NUMBER token there unless you separate the digits with whitespace (I don't know what you really mean there so perhaps it's not an error).

这篇关于即使使用预期的输入，Antlr4也会打印“外部输入"错误的文章就介绍到这了，希望我们推荐的答案对大家有所帮助，也希望大家多多支持IT屋！