所见即所得vs所见即所得 [英] WYSIWYG vs WYSIWYM

问题描述

在基于Web的应用程序中，哪个更好，更理想？

编辑：

实际上，我在开发社区站点。因此，用户级别可能会有所不同。听说过所见即所得编辑器的XSS安全问题。另外，我对所见即所得的编辑器及其功能不熟悉。据我所知，所见即所得编辑器中的功能要比其他功能少。我找到了一个名为 WMD：Wysiwym Markdown编辑器的文件。它非常易于使用。

因此应该有安全性和易用性。在这种情况下，哪个编辑器会更好。

解决方案

如果您的用户可以处理所见即所得，我会考虑的。 / p>

我正在考虑您的系统将是可视的，也就是说，如果您说的是标题，它将看起来像标题（否则WYS部分将不适用）。如果用户必须手动输入标记，那么只有最精通技术的用户才能使用它。

我对大多数用户看到的是，他们难以在文档中赋予他们想要的含义。他们不认为这是标题，而是认为这应该更大，更大胆。不能认为这是标题的人无法处理所见即所得，否则会发现很难。

谁将成为您的用户群？如果是写学术论文的人，那么我会选择所见即所得的，因为他们将不会遇到任何麻烦。如果是给家庭主妇写食谱，他们可能会无法处理，或者会发现它太难了，以至于认为这不值得。

对我来说，理想的是所见即所得，但只有在您认为目标用户能够处理的情况下才这样做，否则就必须使用所见即所得。

Which one is better and ideal in a web based application?

Edit:

Actually I am developing a community site. So the level of users may vary. Heard about XSS security issues with WYSIWYG editors. Also I am not familiar with WYSIWYM editors and its features. As far as I know the features in WYSIWYM editor is less compared to the other one. I figured one named as "WMD: The Wysiwym Markdown Editor". Its quite easy to use.

So security and ease of usability should be there. In such a situation which editor will be better.

解决方案

If your users can handle WYSIWYM, I'd go with that.

I'm considering your system will be visual, that is, if you say something is a title it'll look like a title (otherwise the WYS part wouldn't apply). If the user has to manually type markup, then only the most savvy or technical users will be able to handle it.

What I've seen with most users is that they have trouble giving meaning to what they want in a document. They don't think "this is a title", they think "this should be bigger and bold". People that cannot think "this is a title" can't handle a WYSIWYM or they'll find it hard.

Who is going to be your user base? If it's people writing academic papers I'd go with WYSIWYM because they'll have no trouble handling it. If it's for house wives writing recipes, they may not be able to handle it or they'll find it so hard that they'll decide it's not worth the effort.

For me the ideal is WYSIWYM, but do it only if you think your target users will be able to handle it, otherwise you'll have to go with WYSIWYG.

这篇关于所见即所得vs所见即所得的文章就介绍到这了，希望我们推荐的答案对大家有所帮助，也希望大家多多支持IT屋！