如何在 R 代码中使用异常值测试 [英] How to use Outlier Tests in R Code
问题描述
作为数据分析工作流程的一部分，我想测试异常值，然后在有和没有这些异常值的情况下进行进一步计算.
As part of my data analysis workflow, I want to test for outliers, and then do my further calculation with and without those outliers.
我找到了异常值包，其中包含各种测试，但我不确定如何最好地将它们用于我的工作流程.
I've found the outlier package, which has various tests, but I'm not sure how best to use them for my workflow.
推荐答案
我同意 Dirk 的观点，这很难.我建议先看看为什么你可能会有异常值.异常值只是有人认为可疑的数字，它不是具体的坏"值，除非您能找到将其视为异常值的理由，否则您可能不得不忍受不确定性.
I agree with Dirk, It's hard. I would recomend first looking at why you might have outliers. An outlier is just a number that someone thinks is suspicious, it's not a concrete 'bad' value, and unless you can find a reason for it to be an outlier, you may have to live with the uncertainty.
您没有提到的一件事是您正在查看什么样的异常值.您的数据是否围绕均值聚集，它们是否具有特定分布，或者您的数据之间是否存在某种关系.
One thing you didn't mention was what kind of outlier you're looking at. Are your data clustered around a mean, do they have a particular distribution or is there some relationship between your data.
这里有一些例子
首先，我们将创建一些数据，然后用异常值污染它；
First, we'll create some data, and then taint it with an outlier;
> testout<-data.frame(X1=rnorm(50,mean=50,sd=10),X2=rnorm(50,mean=5,sd=1.5),Y=rnorm(50,mean=200,sd=25))
> #Taint the Data
> testout$X1[10]<-5
> testout$X2[10]<-5
> testout$Y[10]<-530
> testout
X1 X2 Y
1 44.20043 1.5259458 169.3296
2 40.46721 5.8437076 200.9038
3 48.20571 3.8243373 189.4652
4 60.09808 4.6609190 177.5159
5 50.23627 2.6193455 210.4360
6 43.50972 5.8212863 203.8361
7 44.95626 7.8368405 236.5821
8 66.14391 3.6828843 171.9624
9 45.53040 4.8311616 187.0553
10 5.00000 5.0000000 530.0000
11 64.71719 6.4007245 164.8052
12 54.43665 7.8695891 192.8824
13 45.78278 4.9921489 182.2957
14 49.59998 4.7716099 146.3090
<snip>
48 26.55487 5.8082497 189.7901
49 45.28317 5.0219647 208.1318
50 44.84145 3.6252663 251.5620
以图形方式检查数据通常最有用(您的大脑比数学更擅长发现异常值)
It's often most usefull to examine the data graphically (you're brain is much better at spotting outliers than maths is)
> #Use Boxplot to Review the Data
> boxplot(testout$X1, ylab="X1")
> boxplot(testout$X2, ylab="X2")
> boxplot(testout$Y, ylab="Y")
然后就可以使用测试了.如果测试返回一个截止值，或者可能是异常值，您可以使用 ifelse 将其删除
Then you can use a test. If the test returns a cut off value, or the value that might be an outlier, you can use ifelse to remove it
> #Use Outlier test to remove individual values
> testout$newX1<-ifelse(testout$X1==outlier(testout$X1),NA,testout$X1)
> testout
X1 X2 Y newX1
1 44.20043 1.5259458 169.3296 44.20043
2 40.46721 5.8437076 200.9038 40.46721
3 48.20571 3.8243373 189.4652 48.20571
4 60.09808 4.6609190 177.5159 60.09808
5 50.23627 2.6193455 210.4360 50.23627
6 43.50972 5.8212863 203.8361 43.50972
7 44.95626 7.8368405 236.5821 44.95626
8 66.14391 3.6828843 171.9624 66.14391
9 45.53040 4.8311616 187.0553 45.53040
10 5.00000 5.0000000 530.0000 NA
11 64.71719 6.4007245 164.8052 64.71719
12 54.43665 7.8695891 192.8824 54.43665
13 45.78278 4.9921489 182.2957 45.78278
14 49.59998 4.7716099 146.3090 49.59998
15 45.07720 4.2355525 192.9041 45.07720
16 62.27717 7.1518606 186.6482 62.27717
17 48.50446 3.0712422 228.3253 48.50446
18 65.49983 5.4609713 184.8983 65.49983
19 44.38387 4.9305222 213.9378 44.38387
20 43.52883 8.3777627 203.5657 43.52883
<snip>
49 45.28317 5.0219647 208.1318 45.28317
50 44.84145 3.6252663 251.5620 44.84145
或者对于更复杂的示例，您可以使用统计数据来计算临界截止值，此处使用 Lund 检验(参见 Lund，RE 1975，线性模型中异常值的近似检验表"，Technometrics，第 17 卷, no. 4, pp. 473-476. and Prescott, P. 1975, "An Approximate Test for Outliers in Linear Models", Technometrics, vol. 17, no. 1, pp. 129-132.)
Or for more complicated examples, you can use stats to calculate critical cut off values, here using the Lund Test (See Lund, R. E. 1975, "Tables for An Approximate Test for Outliers in Linear Models", Technometrics, vol. 17, no. 4, pp. 473-476. and Prescott, P. 1975, "An Approximate Test for Outliers in Linear Models", Technometrics, vol. 17, no. 1, pp. 129-132.)
> #Alternative approach using Lund Test
> lundcrit<-function(a, n, q) {
+ # Calculates a Critical value for Outlier Test according to Lund
+ # See Lund, R. E. 1975, "Tables for An Approximate Test for Outliers in Linear Models", Technometrics, vol. 17, no. 4, pp. 473-476.
+ # and Prescott, P. 1975, "An Approximate Test for Outliers in Linear Models", Technometrics, vol. 17, no. 1, pp. 129-132.
+ # a = alpha
+ # n = Number of data elements
+ # q = Number of independent Variables (including intercept)
+ F<-qf(c(1-(a/n)),df1=1,df2=n-q-1,lower.tail=TRUE)
+ crit<-((n-q)*F/(n-q-1+F))^0.5
+ crit
+ }
> testoutlm<-lm(Y~X1+X2,data=testout)
> testout$fitted<-fitted(testoutlm)
> testout$residual<-residuals(testoutlm)
> testout$standardresid<-rstandard(testoutlm)
> n<-nrow(testout)
> q<-length(testoutlm$coefficients)
> crit<-lundcrit(0.1,n,q)
> testout$Ynew<-ifelse(abs(testout$standardresid)>crit,NA,testout$Y)
> testout
X1 X2 Y newX1 fitted residual standardresid
1 44.20043 1.5259458 169.3296 44.20043 209.8467 -40.5171222 -1.009507695
2 40.46721 5.8437076 200.9038 40.46721 231.9221 -31.0183107 -0.747624895
3 48.20571 3.8243373 189.4652 48.20571 203.4786 -14.0134646 -0.335955648
4 60.09808 4.6609190 177.5159 60.09808 169.6108 7.9050960 0.190908291
5 50.23627 2.6193455 210.4360 50.23627 194.3285 16.1075799 0.391537883
6 43.50972 5.8212863 203.8361 43.50972 222.6667 -18.8306252 -0.452070155
7 44.95626 7.8368405 236.5821 44.95626 223.3287 13.2534226 0.326339981
8 66.14391 3.6828843 171.9624 66.14391 148.8870 23.0754677 0.568829360
9 45.53040 4.8311616 187.0553 45.53040 214.0832 -27.0279262 -0.646090667
10 5.00000 5.0000000 530.0000 NA 337.0535 192.9465135 5.714275585
11 64.71719 6.4007245 164.8052 64.71719 159.9911 4.8141018 0.118618011
12 54.43665 7.8695891 192.8824 54.43665 194.7454 -1.8630426 -0.046004311
13 45.78278 4.9921489 182.2957 45.78278 213.7223 -31.4266180 -0.751115595
14 49.59998 4.7716099 146.3090 49.59998 201.6296 -55.3205552 -1.321042392
15 45.07720 4.2355525 192.9041 45.07720 213.9655 -21.0613819 -0.504406009
16 62.27717 7.1518606 186.6482 62.27717 169.2455 17.4027250 0.430262983
17 48.50446 3.0712422 228.3253 48.50446 200.6938 27.6314695 0.667366651
18 65.49983 5.4609713 184.8983 65.49983 155.2768 29.6214506 0.726319931
19 44.38387 4.9305222 213.9378 44.38387 217.7981 -3.8603382 -0.092354925
20 43.52883 8.3777627 203.5657 43.52883 228.9961 -25.4303732 -0.634725264
<snip>
49 45.28317 5.0219647 208.1318 45.28317 215.3075 -7.1756966 -0.171560291
50 44.84145 3.6252663 251.5620 44.84145 213.1535 38.4084869 0.923804784
Ynew
1 169.3296
2 200.9038
3 189.4652
4 177.5159
5 210.4360
6 203.8361
7 236.5821
8 171.9624
9 187.0553
10 NA
11 164.8052
12 192.8824
13 182.2957
14 146.3090
15 192.9041
16 186.6482
17 228.3253
18 184.8983
19 213.9378
20 203.5657
<snip>
49 208.1318
50 251.5620
我刚刚注意到我的代码中有一个问题.Lund 检验产生一个临界值，该值应与研究残差的绝对值进行比较(即无符号)
I've just noticed an issue in my code. The Lund test produces a critical value that should be compared to the absolute value of the studantized residual (i.e. without sign)
这篇关于如何在 R 代码中使用异常值测试的文章就介绍到这了，希望我们推荐的答案对大家有所帮助，也希望大家多多支持IT屋！
