生产力：WebForms vs. WinForms [英] Productivity: WebForms vs. WinForms

问题描述

虽然这是一个不可能回答的问题，但无论如何我都不应该提出它。


鉴于相当复杂的ERP应用场景，你对
$的估计是什么？ b $ b X比率


dev。 WebForms应用程序的时间


---------------------------------- - = X


dev。 WinForms应用程序的时间


？


我自己的经验告诉我它应该是2，但同行不同

意见。有些人同意，有人说1，有些人说3 ...


问候，


//MartinRosén-Lidholm


PS对不起，我很想听听两个阵营对这个问题的看法。

Although an impossible question to answer, I fell urged to raise it anyhow.

Given a fairly complex ERP application scenario, what''s your estimation for
the X-ratio

dev. time for WebForms app

----------------------------------- = X

dev. time for WinForms app

?

My own experiences tell me that it should be about 2, but peers differ in
opinion. Some agree, some says 1, and some says 3...

Regards,

// Martin Rosén-Lidholm

PS Sorry for the cross post, but I really would like to hear both camps''
views on this subject.

推荐答案

嗨Martin，


在我看来，开发的这个方面应该来自

的要求而不是时间尺度。


当然现有的技能组成部分，但部署和维护

这些技术之间存在显着差异。


我猜你有一个别有用心的问题。


马丁


"MartinRosén-Lidholm" <毫安***************** @ snabel-a.msn.com>写在

消息新闻：Oq ************** @ tk2msftngp13.phx.gbl ...

Hi Martin,

In my view, this aspect of the development should be driven from the
requirements than the timescales.

Naturally existing skill set plays a part, but deployment and maintenance
are significant differences between these technologies.

I would guess you have an ulterior motive for asking this question.

Martin

"Martin Rosén-Lidholm" <ma*****************@snabel-a.msn.com> wrote in
message news:Oq**************@tk2msftngp13.phx.gbl...

虽然这是一个不可能的问题回答，无论如何我不得不提高它
。

鉴于一个相当复杂的ERP应用场景，你估计的X比率为


dev。 WebForms应用程序的时间

----------------------------------- = X

dev。 WinForms应用程序的时间



我自己的经验告诉我它应该是2，但同行的意见不同。有些人同意，有些人说1，有些人说3 ......

问候，

//MartinRosén-Lidholm

PS对不起交叉发帖，但我真的很想听听两个阵营对这个主题的看法。

Although an impossible question to answer, I fell urged to raise it anyhow.
Given a fairly complex ERP application scenario, what''s your estimation for the X-ratio

dev. time for WebForms app

----------------------------------- = X

dev. time for WinForms app

?

My own experiences tell me that it should be about 2, but peers differ in
opinion. Some agree, some says 1, and some says 3...

Regards,

// Martin Rosén-Lidholm

PS Sorry for the cross post, but I really would like to hear both camps''
views on this subject.

Martin，


感谢您的回复。


不，我的动机不是不可思议的;-)


我得出结论，两种技术都可以满足手头项目的功能性和非功能性b $ b要求。


因为我相信它会花费我们两倍的时间使用WebForms（技能组合

非常多样化而且不赞成任何两种），我想通知

管理这个。


然而，我的信念并没有被分享，所以我试图用这个线程扩大讨论基础

。


// Martin

" Martin" < x@y.z>在留言中写道

新闻：％2 **************** @ TK2MSFTNGP09.phx.gbl ...

Martin,

Thank you for your reply.

No, my motives aren''t ulterior ;-)

I''ve come to the conclusion that the functional and non-functional
requirements of the project at hand can be met with both technologies.

Since I believe it''ll take us twice the time using WebForms (the skill set
is very diverse and not in favor of any of the two), I''d like to notify
management about this.

However, my belief isn''t shared, so I tried to broaden the discussion base
with this thread.

// Martin
"Martin" <x@y.z> wrote in message
news:%2****************@TK2MSFTNGP09.phx.gbl...

嗨Martin ，

在我看来，开发的这个方面应该来自
要求而不是时间尺度。

自然存在的技能组成部分，但部署和维护
这些技术之间存在显着差异。

我猜你有一个别有用心的问题。

Martin
MartinRosén-Lidholm <毫安***************** @ snabel-a.msn.com>在消息新闻中写道：Oq ************** @ tk2msftngp13.phx.gbl ...

Hi Martin,

In my view, this aspect of the development should be driven from the
requirements than the timescales.

Naturally existing skill set plays a part, but deployment and maintenance
are significant differences between these technologies.

I would guess you have an ulterior motive for asking this question.

Martin

"Martin Rosén-Lidholm" <ma*****************@snabel-a.msn.com> wrote in
message news:Oq**************@tk2msftngp13.phx.gbl...

虽然一个不可能回答的问题，我摔倒了无论如何都要求提高它

Although an impossible question to answer, I fell urged to raise it

。

鉴于一个相当复杂的ERP应用场景，你的估计是什么

Given a fairly complex ERP application scenario, what''s your estimation

for

for

X比率

dev。 WebForms应用程序的时间

----------------------------------- = X

dev。 WinForms应用程序的时间



我自己的经验告诉我它应该是2，但同行的意见不同
。有些人同意，有些人说1，有些人说3 ......

问候，

//MartinRosén-Lidholm

PS对不起我希望听到两个阵营对这个主题的看法。

the X-ratio

dev. time for WebForms app

----------------------------------- = X

dev. time for WinForms app

?

My own experiences tell me that it should be about 2, but peers differ in opinion. Some agree, some says 1, and some says 3...

Regards,

// Martin Rosén-Lidholm

PS Sorry for the cross post, but I really would like to hear both camps''
views on this subject.

如果你是自己的老板，你会用哪个？ （听起来像窗户

形式）。


谁将使用该系统，以及你有多少用户？


您是否有想与我们分享的简短系统规格？


Martin

"MartinRosén- Lidholm" <毫安***************** @ snabel-a.msn.com>写在

消息新闻：uH ************** @ TK2MSFTNGP09.phx.gbl ...

If you were your own boss, which would you use? (Sounds like windows
forms).

Who''s going to use the system, and how many users to you have?

Do you have a brief system spec you''d like to share with us?

Martin
"Martin Rosén-Lidholm" <ma*****************@snabel-a.msn.com> wrote in
message news:uH**************@TK2MSFTNGP09.phx.gbl...

Martin，
感谢您的回复。

不，我的动机不是不可思议的;-)

我得出的结论是功能性的两种技术都可以满足手头项目的非功能性要求。

因为我认为使用WebForms需要两倍的时间（技能组合） >非常多元化，不赞成两者中的任何一个），我想通知
管理层。

然而，我的信念并没有分享，所以我试图用这个帖子扩大讨论基础。

// Martin

" Martin" < x@y.z>在消息中写道
新闻：％2 **************** @ TK2MSFTNGP09.phx.gbl ...

Martin,

Thank you for your reply.

No, my motives aren''t ulterior ;-)

I''ve come to the conclusion that the functional and non-functional
requirements of the project at hand can be met with both technologies.

Since I believe it''ll take us twice the time using WebForms (the skill set
is very diverse and not in favor of any of the two), I''d like to notify
management about this.

However, my belief isn''t shared, so I tried to broaden the discussion base
with this thread.

// Martin
"Martin" <x@y.z> wrote in message
news:%2****************@TK2MSFTNGP09.phx.gbl...

嗨Martin，
在我看来，开发的这个方面应该来自
要求而不是时间尺度。

当然现有的技能组成部分，但部署和
维护

Hi Martin,

In my view, this aspect of the development should be driven from the
requirements than the timescales.

Naturally existing skill set plays a part, but deployment and maintenance

这些技术之间存在显着差异。

我猜你有一个别有用心的问题。

Martin

MartinRosén-Lidholm <毫安***************** @ snabel-a.msn.com>在消息新闻中写道：Oq ************** @ tk2msftngp13.phx.gbl ...

are significant differences between these technologies.

I would guess you have an ulterior motive for asking this question.

Martin

"Martin Rosén-Lidholm" <ma*****************@snabel-a.msn.com> wrote in
message news:Oq**************@tk2msftngp13.phx.gbl...

虽然一个不可能回答的问题，我摔倒了无论如何都要提高它

Although an impossible question to answer, I fell urged to raise it

。

鉴于一个相当复杂的ERP应用场景，你的
估算是什么

Given a fairly complex ERP application scenario, what''s your estimation

for

X比率

dev。 WebForms应用程序的时间

----------------------------------- = X

dev。 WinForms应用程序的时间



我自己的经验告诉我它应该是2，但同行不同

the X-ratio

dev. time for WebForms app

----------------------------------- = X

dev. time for WinForms app

?

My own experiences tell me that it should be about 2, but peers differ

意见。有些人同意，有些人说1，有些人说3 ......

问候，

//MartinRosén-Lidholm

PS对不起交叉发帖，但我真的很想听到

in opinion. Some agree, some says 1, and some says 3...

Regards,

// Martin Rosén-Lidholm

PS Sorry for the cross post, but I really would like to hear both

camps'对这个主题的看法。

camps'' views on this subject.

这篇关于生产力：WebForms vs. WinForms的文章就介绍到这了，希望我们推荐的答案对大家有所帮助，也希望大家多多支持IT屋！