喜欢按钮和隐私问题 [英] Like button and privacy concern

问题描述

我正在欧盟内部运营一个网站，如今没有办法没有这些社交按钮(根据他们"那里"的说法).

I'm operating a website within the EU and nowadays there's no way without those social buttons all around (according to "them" "up there").

最近有人担心在欧盟的合法性，尤其是未经用户明确同意而发送到美国服务器的用户信息收集.

Recently there's a concern about the legality of this in the EU, notably the collection of user information sent to the US servers without explicit user consent.

关于golem.de的德国报告以及律师的建议(仅对不起，仅德语)，如果集成的赞"按钮不会自动触发与美国服务器本身的交互，而仅在用户同意的情况下，即手动交互(例如单击)，就足够了.

There was a German report on golem.de, along with advice from a lawyer (sorry, German only) that it would be sufficient if the integrated like button would not automatically trigger an interaction with the US server per se, but only with user consent, i.e. manual interaction such as the click.

我们目前将官方纳入方法与订阅edge.create 事件以了解其事件用法.但不幸的是，这可以通过向iframe加载来自Facebook的内容来实现，这样就可以在未经用户 同意的情况下立即发送有关用户的数据，甚至无需他就单击它.我想办法避免这种情况.

We currently use the official method of inclusion along with subscribing to the edge.create event to get some sense of its usage. But unfortunately this works by loading an iframe with content from Facebook, thus immediately sending data about the user without his consent, without him even clicking on it. I seek a way to avoid that.

想法:显示带有本地href的本地图像，仅当用户实际单击时，该图像才开始加载Facebook内容.

Idea: Show a local image with a local href which starts loading the Facebook stuff only when user actually clicks on it.

我所看到的问题:

1. 用户单击我的DOM元素，现在我需要像实际的FB按钮一样被按下，但是由于没有真正的按钮，我该怎么办?如果我加载该按钮，则用户会看到第二个按钮，需要再次单击，依此类推.如果不在屏幕上，则需要加载该按钮，伪造该点击，等等.复杂而混乱.
2. 点赞旁边的计数器会丢失.我需要找到一种方法来获取当前URL的信息(例如服务器端)，智能地缓存该数据并仍然能够向用户显示该信息.我不知道从哪里获得这些数据.

无论是否在欧盟内，无论是否在法律内，由于我只是在最近才开始研究此问题(因为我的工作要求这样做)，当我意识到它的真正工作原理时，这使我感到无所适从.我是一个网络偏执狂，简直不敢相信我一个人.

Being within EU or not, law or not, since I started only recently looking into this (because my job demanded it), it got me the creeps when I realized how it really works. I'm a web paranoid, can't believe I'm alone.

有什么办法解决上述问题吗?

Any ideas how to tackle the above problems?

推荐答案

对我来说，最终的解决方案是德国新闻门户网站heise.de如何实施它.

For me, the ultimate solution is how the German news portal heise.de implemented it.

不幸的是，所有内容都是德语的，但是他们的解决方案是改为在之前显示虚拟图片，并允许用户有选择地在整个网站上使用它.请参见德语或

Unfortunately it's all in German, but their solution is to show a dummy picture before instead and allow the user to selectively allow it for the whole site. See the article in German or Google translation to English.

这引起了一些用户的兴趣(德语文章，

This created quite some user interested (German article, Google translation to English) and has already called Facebook (presumably from Germany) on the plan, as they wrote in their article, that it is against their policy to use their button in they way they did.

更新:

现在它击中了Slashdot: Heise的两次单击以获取更多隐私"与Facebook

And now it hit Slashdot: Heise's 'Two Clicks For More Privacy' vs. Facebook

这篇关于喜欢按钮和隐私问题的文章就介绍到这了，希望我们推荐的答案对大家有所帮助，也希望大家多多支持IT屋！