您推荐哪种 Swing 布局? [英] Which Swing layout(s) do you recommend?

问题描述

仅 Java 库中就有 8 个布局管理器，然后还有一堆 3rd 方产品.

There are 8 layout managers in the Java library alone, and then there's a bunch of 3rd party products as well.

前几天，我尝试使用 SpringLayout 并且......好吧，它对我不起作用.请参阅我的其他问题.所以...如果您有一个 Swing 应用程序要设计，并且您希望您的布局恰到好处，那么您首选的布局管理器是什么?有什么有趣/有用的经历可以联系起来?

The other day, I tried to use SpringLayout and... well, it ain't working out for me. See my other question. So... if you have a Swing app to design, and you want your layout just so, what are your preferred layout managers? Any interesting/useful experiences to relate?

更新: 是的，我知道不同的 LM 适用于不同的布局.但我希望你们中的大多数人在所做的大多数事情中都使用 1、2 或 3，或者您发誓使用一个如此多才多艺的人，您永远不需要其他任何东西.有了足够的响应，我希望看到类似钟形曲线的东西，在 GridBagLayout 或 MigLayout(例如)上有一个峰值，以及一些使用(比如)BoxLayout 或 FlowLayout 的落后者的长尾.

Update: Yup, sure I'm aware that different LMs are appropriate for different layouts. But I'd expect that most of you use 1, 2 or maybe 3 for most everything you do, or you swear by a single one that's so versatile you never need anything else. With enough responses, I'd expect to see something like a bell curve, with a peak on GridBagLayout or MigLayout (for example) and a long tail of a few stragglers using (say) BoxLayout or FlowLayout.

希望回复的分布能够揭示人们最常使用什么来完成工作™

Hopefully, the distribution of responses will reveal some trends as to what people use most to Get Stuff Done™

好吧，差不多2天后，MiGLayout绝对领先！它的粉丝会很高兴听到这个布局看起来很快就会进入官方"库.

OK, after almost 2 days, MiGLayout is definitely out in front! Its fans will be happy to hear that it looks like this layout will be entering the "official" library soon.

GroupLayout、FormsLayout 和 TableLayout 相对较新，并没有得到太多曝光.也许其他人会和我一样惊讶地发现他们.

GroupLayout, FormsLayout and TableLayout are relatively new and haven't gotten much exposure. Perhaps others will be as surprised to find out about them as I was.

推荐答案

MiGLayout，毫无疑问.老实说，这是我所知道的唯一一个有意义的 Swing 布局管理器.

MiGLayout, no doubt. Honestly, it's the only Swing layout manager I know of that makes any sense.

核心 JDK 中有 8 个布局管理器这一事实表明，Swing 创建者完全不知道他们要做什么.这并不是要破坏 Swing 的其余部分 - 除了布局管理器之外，它是一个很好的 GUI 工具包.

The mere fact that there are 8 layout managers in the core JDK is a good sign that the Swing creators had absolutely no idea about what they were trying to do. This is not to trash the rest of the Swing - it's a good GUI toolkit, except for the layout managers.

这篇关于您推荐哪种 Swing 布局?的文章就介绍到这了，希望我们推荐的答案对大家有所帮助，也希望大家多多支持IT屋！